Jon
Admin
Posts: 6,912
|
Post by Jon on Nov 4, 2012 13:22:16 GMT
I think the point is more that 1) this isn't the first dreadful performance this season and 2) it's not like Ling can drop many players to kick some of these guys up the arse for this because he doesn't have the options to do so - why should the players bother when they know that even if they play badly they're not going to lose their spot in the team, especially when if they win, they may not be guaranteed their places? Either way, it's rather pathetic. Bar the small number of "get a sense of perspective" comments (valid but missing the point that it's been a consistent thing), the vast majority of posts here and elsewhere have basically said that this was atrocious. Considering Ling said earlier this week about needing a cup run, and then seemingly defending the players when they didn't do what he expected of them, this is an absolute mess - a first team that can only lift itself against strong opposition, several players consistently under-performing, no money to improve it thanks to the cup exits, and a manager who doesn't seem to have a grip on what's going on. If we didn't have the league position for people to use to defend the club with (and I think we're fortunate to be in the position we're in, judging by what I've read here lately), Ling would be under serious pressure right now Credit to Harrogate and all that but it sounds as if it was more using losing rather than them winning. I know that's what happens with most giant-killings to an extent, but the fact that this isn't the first time I'm seeing comments like "this is the worst performance for years" (and whether or not that's true is besides the point) suggests this isn't just because it was the FA Cup - we're genuinely not playing well and I'm getting concerned If my auntie had bollocks, she'd be my uncle. If we were bottom of the league, Martin Ling would be under serious pressure right now. My auntie does not have bollocks (actually, I don't have an auntie but bear with me), we are sat in the play-off zone and Martin Ling is not under serious pressure right now. How we come to be sat in the play-off zone is a complete mystery with "players consistently under-performing" and "a manager who doesn't seem to have a grip on what's going on". Some fool might look at the league table and say we cannot possibly be as bad as all that, but James has read on the internet that we are an awful team with a crap manager and players who cannot be bothered, so it must be true. Yesterday was bad. We played badly, Harrogate played well. Despite not really getting going, we still missed a hatful of straightforward chances to win the game. The loss is a severe financial blow. It will probably restrict inward transfer movement and increase the risk of outward transfer movement. That is a shame, but it is not the end of the world. We are the seventeenth biggest club in the division. I still think our excellent management team will deliver better than seventeenth place and so beat par. We will still have a go for the top seven. With the extra funding from a cup run, I would almost have fancied our chances. Without it, it would be an achievement of near-Leroyesque proportions if we could pull it off.
|
|
JamesB
TFF member
Posts: 1,526
|
Post by JamesB on Nov 4, 2012 13:26:47 GMT
Burton sat in a similar position to us last year and people were wondering how that had happened given that they were nothing special
They soon got found out, the manager ended up out of a job and they were lucky to not get relegated
You can't keep winning despite performing badly forever in this division. Our form is not that good if you look at actual performances - we were poor against Morecambe, we were poor against Bristol Rovers, we were very poor against Wycombe and we were dreadful in the first half against Aldershot. That's 2 and a half good performances out of the last 7 in the last month. We've been very lucky to get 12 points from those 6 league matches
I've always been sceptical of the term "regression to the mean" but there is evidence to suggest it could be a real thing, the idea being that you can't keep overachieving forever
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 4, 2012 13:53:52 GMT
Wise words from Jon.
Yesterday looks a calamity from here.
But not part of an ongoing disaster that is heading for the rocks. Not my view anyway. Not today.
Shrewsbury, Swindon and Colchester are bigger clubs with better teams than us.
But they lost to non-league teams yesterday.
The crowds were crap just about everywhere. Sadly, the FA Cup has lost something of its allure.
Will losing to a non-league side lead to a plague of locusts being unleashed upon Plainmoor?
I know not. I must look at the tea leaves some time.
For the record our last non-league defeat was Crawley the season before last (with them also defeating Swindon, Derby, Bury, Bristol City and Hull either side of us).
It may not be relevant to what happens next. But our league record since that Crawley defeat has been absolutely bloody superb!
|
|
|
Post by loyalgull on Nov 4, 2012 14:34:35 GMT
northampton v bradford yesterday,attracted 2500 fans,a shocking attendance considering northampton average 5000ish and bradford around 10000,as bartondowns rightly says it isnt the big crowd puller it was.To much obcession with champions league stuff.Shame as its still a great competition,but crowds arent what they used to be for this fine competition
|
|
|
Post by stefano on Nov 4, 2012 14:56:13 GMT
Nice to read some sound common sense from Jon. When I looked in here at about midnight last night I thought it must be a full moon!
|
|
|
Post by jmgull on Nov 4, 2012 14:57:58 GMT
Burton sat in a similar position to us last year and people were wondering how that had happened given that they were nothing special They soon got found out, the manager ended up out of a job and they were lucky to not get relegated You can't keep winning despite performing badly forever in this division. Our form is not that good if you look at actual performances - we were poor against Morecambe, we were poor against Bristol Rovers, we were very poor against Wycombe and we were dreadful in the first half against Aldershot. That's 2 and a half good performances out of the last 7 in the last month. We've been very lucky to get 12 points from those 6 league matches I've always been sceptical of the term "regression to the mean" but there is evidence to suggest it could be a real thing, the idea being that you can't keep overachieving forever James........I fear for your sanity I really do, we weren't lucky to get 12 points from the last 6 matches, we're not lucky to be 7th in the league - you get what you deserve in football. You're becoming the evil re-incarnation of Fonda....
|
|
JamesB
TFF member
Posts: 1,526
|
Post by JamesB on Nov 4, 2012 15:10:16 GMT
you get what you deserve in football.. This isn't true. This whole idea that luck balances out is nonsense. The tiniest decisions have enormous impacts The fact is we have been played off the park by some terrible teams of late, including now a team 2 divisions below who played 120 minutes on Wednesday. This isn't a one-off - it's been a consistent thing. It's only going to be a matter of time before we're going to lose at home in the league, and at some point a team is going to turn up against us and hit 5 or 6 past us Just because we're 7th doesn't make us a good team. It just means we're less bad than the teams below us. That won't last forever - teams will find consistency. I can't see where we're going to get it from. One step forward, two steps back I don't care where we are in the table. Look at the performances. They are a much better indicator of where we are at the moment, because it's still early in the season. We've had a lot of easy games of late against poor sides and yet we still haven't taken full advantage of them. Judge by where we should be, based on the fixtures - and where we should be is in the automatic promotion spots. And the 2nd Round of the FA Cup
|
|
|
Post by Swanny on Nov 4, 2012 15:18:27 GMT
Looking at the match highlights on ITV Player, it looks like Rene's offside goal was actually onside. Bodin actually does very well to win the ball and put Howe through. You do not see Howe in the film when the ball from Bodin is played but shortly afterwards Howe is seen just beyond the last defender. Howe was probably level when the ball was played.
Ofcourse it is irrelevant now but it goes to show the fine line between success and failure. One dubious decision can change everything. The other point to make is that Bodin's build up play is often very good, sadly it's just his finishing that has gone to pot. Yes yesterday was a huge downer and setback but the club on and off the pitch is still doing well. We need to get a sense of perspective. If we were at the bottom of the league, that's the time to worry. I've seen at lot worse over the years. Yesterday could have been much different if that decision had gone our way. I think Ling considering the players he has lost and the transfer money he has brought in has done quite a remarkable job since he joined on limited resources.
|
|
|
Post by Swanny on Nov 4, 2012 15:18:57 GMT
Looking at the match highlights on ITV Player, it looks like Rene's offside goal was actually onside. Bodin actually does very well to win the ball and put Howe through. You do not see Howe in the film when the ball from Bodin is played but shortly afterwards Howe is seen just beyond the last defender. Howe was probably level when the ball was played.
Ofcourse it is irrelevant now but it goes to show the fine line between success and failure. One dubious decision can change everything. The other point to make is that Bodin's build up play is often very good, sadly it's just his finishing that has gone to pot. Yes yesterday was a huge downer and setback but the club on and off the pitch is still doing well. We need to get a sense of perspective. If we were at the bottom of the league, that's the time to worry. I've seen at lot worse over the years. Yesterday could have been much different if that decision had gone our way. I think Ling considering the players he has lost and the transfer money he has brought in has done quite a remarkable job since he joined on limited resources.
|
|
|
Post by lambethgull on Nov 4, 2012 15:23:41 GMT
I think the doom-mongers on here are getting a bit carried away tbh.
Going out at home to a non-league side in the 1st round is disappointing, and none of us are looking forward to the stick we'll get for that. But we've done well in the FAC in recent seasons, and there are plenty of clubs who will have been disappointed to go out to us. On the balance of probabilities I think it was always likely that we were going to have a poor showing sooner or later.
We all know the squad's limitations, but we're 7th and we're more than holding our own in the league table. Is it really a huge surprise that an up-for-it non-league side put in a solid performance and took advantage of some poor finishing from us and went home winners? I don't think it is, and I think some of us need to get a grip.
|
|
JamesB
TFF member
Posts: 1,526
|
Post by JamesB on Nov 4, 2012 16:09:44 GMT
On the balance of probabilities I think it was always likely that we were going to have a poor showing sooner or later. But this isn't just 1 poor showing. It's a series of poor showings. At the moment it's the good performance against Gillingham that's the anomaly We all know the squad's limitations, but we're 7th and we're more than holding our own in the league table. This may be, but we also have the same number of points after 15 matches as Macclesfield last year Bar the top 2 who are clearly streets ahead of the mess that lies behind them, it's still far too early to read anything into this table. The table is only fully representative when every team has played every other team home and away. The difficulty of matches therefore has to be taken into account when looking at the table at this stage, and while we are 7th, we could be much higher had we beaten the "poor" teams in the division Instead of focusing on position, which is totally unrepresentative, look at points - we are only 1 point closer to the top than we are to the relegation zone. It's not all that great. This is a very poor League Two and it's incredibly frustrating to see us blow this, because had we performed to our potential instead of consistent under-performance against teams like Wycombe and Rovers, we could be in the title hunt
|
|
|
Post by stuartB on Nov 4, 2012 16:20:33 GMT
I think the match sponsors and sunday independent got it wrong. For me Leadbitter played well. I like the look of this guy as he has pace and likes to get forward. He needs to work on his defensive side but no more that Oastler does. It was bad yesterday but no the end of the world, that comes when we lost to Barnet, Oxford and Dagenham Jon, when are these flood gates going to open?
|
|
Dave
TFF member
Posts: 13,081
|
Post by Dave on Nov 4, 2012 17:10:26 GMT
There have been so many good points raised on this match day thread both positive and some showing some concerns. No one could ever say the club is not in good hands and has made great progress since the day we lost our league status.
There is a world of difference from not actually and learning the result later, than having paid to watch it and go through the whole entire emotions one does at a football match. I know both Petef and Loyalgull very well, good solid fans of Torquay United who have stood by the club through the good and the bad days.
It does concern me when I read posts from the diehard types of fans, where they start questioning if they want to turn up for the next home match, based on what they were served up. How they must have felt when they left the ground would have been far different from how I felt when I learned the result on the radio.
Our James is no Fonda and never will be and he sure is not some stupid person who talks out of his ass, he sees what he considers to be genuine concerns and does put them across very well. I happen to agree with many of the points he has raised and think it would be foolish for anyone to just look at our league placing and start ignoring our performances.
The next six or so games could see us firmly cemented in a play-off place, but they could also see us drop very close the bottom of the table. None of us can with any degree of confidence, where in the table we will be after Christmas or at the end of the season for that matters.
The question is do we have a big and strong enough squad to keep us near the top of the table? Or are we in danger of running out of steam like we did last season, only this time that situation could come much earlier.
It has rightly been pointed out that being out of the cup so soon has cost the club dearly, where can the money come from now to try and strengthen the squad because it needs to be as I can’t see how we can stay near the top with the small squad we do have.
Maybe we can and the views I have expressed as they are only my own opinions could be so far of the mark. Only time is going to tell one way or the other and I never see anyone on here as a moaner as such, just someone who has concerns because they love, support and want the best for the club.
|
|
|
Post by loyalgull on Nov 4, 2012 17:27:40 GMT
I think the match sponsors and sunday independent got it wrong. For me Leadbitter played well. I like the look of this guy as he has pace and likes to get forward. He needs to work on his defensive side but no more that Oastler does. It was bad yesterday but no the end of the world, that comes when we lost to Barnet, Oxford and Dagenham Jon, when are these flood gates going to open? i thought leadbitter did well,but most of the others
|
|
Jon
Admin
Posts: 6,912
|
Post by Jon on Nov 4, 2012 17:29:45 GMT
Just because we're 7th doesn't make us a good team. It just means we're less bad than the teams below us. No shit Sherlock! Welcome to League 2!
|
|