Jon
Admin
Posts: 6,912
|
Post by Jon on Dec 10, 2016 9:05:22 GMT
As requested by TUST board member, and former club CEO, Andy Candy:
As you are probably aware I have recently been appointed to the TUST board to help with HR and Fund Raising. At the AGM tonight I raised the important question as to how TUST can do more to communicate and engage with all fans, regardless of whether they are TUST members or not. I am aware through being a regular visitor to this site that it is an issue that is causing concern and that TUST has been criticised by some people for not raising its profile high enough to non-TUST supporters. I also believe that that if the Club has any chance of surviving the silent and apathetic majority of fans need to be educated to make informed decisions about whether they support community ownership or not.
To try and address this I put forward a number of suggestions including raising the TUST profile on our three fans forums. This was approved and I offered to contact you to seek permission to set up a formal TUST thread. This will be used by the TUST Board to post information direct rather than rely on the goodwill of people like yourself to reproduce TUST communications for everyone to read.
If you are in agreement, I would be very grateful if you could establish a new permanent thread on your site with a simple heading of TUST UPDATE.
I am happy if you need to use this email to publicise why a new thread has been created.
Thank you for your time.
Best regards,
Andrew
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 10, 2016 10:21:15 GMT
Wish you the best of luck Andrew! People need to listen too and trust Andy, he's a good man!
|
|
|
Post by andycandy on Dec 10, 2016 11:56:52 GMT
Thanks very much Aussie. I just want to make sure that information is available to all fans whether they are TUST members or not. This will allow supporters to make their own informed decisions rather than rely on rumour, speculation or someone else's interpretation of what is being said. The TUST communications to their members are very good and on behalf of TUST, I am very pleased and grateful that all three forums have agreed to my request.
|
|
|
Post by andycandy on Dec 10, 2016 21:58:45 GMT
Hi FloridaGull, Thank you for your comments. I did raise the use of "traditional" media outlets including the Herald, WMN and local radio as possibly the majority of TUFC supporters are not forum users or follow the Club using social media.I was told that the Herald has given TUST some coverage in the past and WMN has been approached, but not with any great success. The challenge therefore is to reach the fans that turn up most weeks, pay the entrance fee (whether as a season ticket holder or through the turnstiles), then go home happy if we win, disappointed if we lose. The notion that the Club might be in crisis is however lost on a lot of them. TUST has to connect with these people in order to educate them as to the scale of the problems and the action TUST is planning to take to try and somehow make things better. Fans can then make their own decision whether they think TUST is the right way forward for them. If there is news this coming week about the new owners TUST will issue a statement and I hope will approach all forms of media to deliver that message, which of course will be dependent on who the new owners are. TUST recognises the importance of engaging with all supporters on this major issue so hopefully the message will be communicated to the majority of the fan base.
|
|
petef
Match Room Manager
Posts: 4,626
|
Post by petef on Dec 11, 2016 11:48:06 GMT
Engaging only with fans - ie. "supporters" will never be enough, its the general public the TUST needs to get on board but firstly the new owmers must find ways to connect and promote the club to the non football people of the bay. I would like to believe that any new owner will have some sound and perhaps radical plans for the future of the club not only as a football club but as a business. The current model has run its course, is unsuccssesfull and completely out of date and for the club to continue to exist we need some drastic radical thinking as it's highly unlikely the prospective new owners will be throwing cash or pension funds into a bottomless pit. Of course It resmains to be seen who these people are and what the underlying motive is to take on a failing sporting business. I predict just as when Roberts gained control there will be press calls with all of the who har with promises of a great future for the football club etc etc. Persoanlly all I wold like to hear are realistic plans that at least bring the stability that offers the club a chance to at least survive at this level with some hope to build a better future back in the football league. After all continue as we are and more and more of the so called hard core support will just drift away as the majority are only in it to be entertained and associate themselves with a successful football club and not be embarrased to wear the colours.
|
|
|
Post by andycandy on Dec 14, 2016 12:08:41 GMT
For those of you who have not seen the Herald Express today.
AS TORQUAY United head towards their own Takeover Deadline Day this Friday, the club's Supporters' Trust have launched a Pre-Share Issue – in case the Gulls' current sale deal falls through.
TUST has received more than £20,000 in pledges in less than two weeks, but it's money they hope they never have to ask for.
Eighteen months after chairman David Phillips' board assumed control, a group including major creditors Gaming International and Truro City chairman Peter Masters remains the favourite to take over United.
All other contenders, either rejected or withdrawn, appear to have faded out of the picture.
Swindon-based GI's previous interest stalled in July after failed talks with landlords Torbay Council over the freehold of Plainmoor.
But before then they are believed to have drawn up plans for a new-look board as well as staff changes.
They remain decisive players, particularly because of loans of more than £100,000 they have made to the club, reportedly with the current board's shares as security.
Those loans are due to be repaid by January 31.
Masters also paid over a considerable five-figure sum, to secure a Torquay-Truro ground-share option which is still in place.
With money so short, during a month without home-game revenue until the Boxing Day meeting with Forest Green Rovers, United urgently need an injection of funds from somewhere.
Their last bulletin was on November 30, when they announced a 'sale agreement subject to final contract and due diligence', accompanied by the December 16 completion date.
Phillips did say on Monday afternoon, after a key board meeting: "Nothing has been signed as I speak.
"But by the end of business on Friday we will know where we are going.
"We will issue a statement of where we are as a club."
The fact that, with a deal apparently so close, the prospective buyers have still not made themselves public or issued a statement about their future plans is of growing concern to Gulls fans.
The Vanarama National League board is also understood to be watching the situation at Plainmoor closely.
TUST stress that their pre-share issue is not a request for money at this stage.
"If the board succeed in securing investment that is in the club's best long-term interest, then we will suspend the pre-issue and deposit money can be returned," said a Trust spokesman.
"If, however, negotiations fail, we hope that the directors will have enough confidence to at least give the supporters a chance to answer the community ownership question.
"Since the 'soft' launch of the share-issue on December 1, we have had just over £20,000 in pledges.
"We are not fund-raising. The pre-issue is an opportunity for all supporters to demonstrate their confidence in a 'community share issue' should the need arise.
"Unlike other fundraising initiatives (such as crowd-funding), supporters will get their deposits returned on request."
Supporters' Direct club development manager James Mathie commented: "It's one thing a club being saved, but it needs to be a long-term solution from buyers with the club's best intentions at heart, or we could easily be in the same situation again in 12 months' time.
"By asking people to deposit money, alongside a pledge, it gives you a better idea of who would support a community takeover and how much money could be raised.
"It can also unlock new interest from outside the normal supporter base, and you can see a real momentum build as people get a better understanding and interest of owning their club."
|
|
rjdgull
TFF member
Admin
Posts: 12,227
|
Post by rjdgull on Dec 14, 2016 13:59:15 GMT
Very sad it has come to this but lack of any positive snippets of news was indicating the increasing probability of this being the case. So ownership is about to pass into the hands of Pete "trusted advisor" Masters and "not the best of bedfellows" GI. What this means is not clear.....
No doubt this means that the Board have not got their asking price which was always pie in the sky thinking but how sad that even at this late stage they could not approach TUST and shows up their gamble of rejecting help from TUST who have been continually rejected beyond the point of no return.
|
|
Mark L
TFF member
Posts: 324
Favourite Player: Paul Baker
|
Post by Mark L on Dec 14, 2016 14:27:55 GMT
Very sad it has come to this but lack of any positive snippets of news was indicating the increasing probability of this being the case. So ownership is about to pass into the hands of Pete "trusted advisor" Masters and "not the best of bedfellows" GI. What this means is not clear..... No doubt this means that the Board have not got their asking price which was always pie in the sky thinking but how sad that even at this late stage they could not approach TUST and shows up their gamble of rejecting help from TUST who have been continually rejected beyond the point of no return. A big thank you to Kelvin Thomas who, with his 'expert knowledge', handed the club to some people with barely a penny between them and ignored the potential for community ownership despite its proven success elsewhere. We've been left with a club in debt, at it's lowest point on the field since the 1920s and a group of worn-down supporters. I do feel sorry for Thea. She's a good egg and tried her best to get out while leaving us in good hands. Now we have been plunged into the abyss. Phoenix club or raise £150k to pay off GI? Maybe that second ship has sailed.
|
|
rjdgull
TFF member
Admin
Posts: 12,227
|
Post by rjdgull on Dec 16, 2016 22:46:33 GMT
TUST update this evening titled "disgraceful" drawing on DP "not the best bedfellows" and no contact with GI comments.
I think the Board were genuinely looking elsewhere but not with realistic terms and it was all so predictable that we are where we are.....
|
|
|
Post by andycandy on Dec 17, 2016 7:58:43 GMT
Please see TUST statement issued today. DISGRACEFUL. Dear Member ...
The sense of betrayal by those purporting to call themselves supporters is palpable.
To accept and indeed value advice from the heavily rumoured person whose withdrawn bid in 2015 opened the doors to Dean Edwards and his failed consortium beggars belief.
To refuse offers of free help and advice from all corners in preference to their chosen special advisor has always rang alarm bells and it is now apparent that it was not just TUST that has been kept at arms length.
To publicly deny any involvement with any of the parties who will now take ownership of the club only goes to demonstrate the level of contempt held towards the very life blood of our club.
The board should hang their heads in shame!
TUST originally set up the Community Shares Pre-Issue offer to give the directors confidence that there was enough financial support amongst the fans to make supporter ownership a viable option. What I have always suspected has now been confirmed and there was never any sincere intention by the directors to consider supporter ownership and the cynic in me questions whether we have arrived at a destination that was planned some time ago.
Now we turn our attention to securing Plainmoor whilst planning for the wildly predicted financial crisis that awaits.
I call on EVERY Torquay United Supporter to get involved and help build the funds that will inevitably be needed.
I urge you all to click on the following link, move the video at the suggested time line.
“5 mins – 37 seconds” - David Phillips give his opinion of Gaming International “8 mins – 42 seconds” - David Phillips denies contact with Gaming International
Kind Regards...
Michael
|
|
Rob
TFF member
Posts: 3,607
Favourite Player: Asa Hall
|
Post by Rob on Dec 17, 2016 17:19:38 GMT
It worked for Reading Speedway. What could possibly go wrong with property developers. Hey Flo. Continuous bashing of a supporters group. 'Let it go' love.
Agree about supporters still supporting the team, though. Each to their own as well. Good point and clean sheet today delivered by Manager and team.
|
|
petef
Match Room Manager
Posts: 4,626
|
Post by petef on Dec 17, 2016 18:08:02 GMT
Rob I dont think its supporter group bashing its just another point of view and believe its important that every supporter has a voice and a viewpoint that is respected. We're all guilty of tunell vision, seeing things only from our own perspective whilst ignoring reasoned argument. None of us have all of the facts to make an honest judgement so it makes sense in my eyes to wait and listen to see what is forthcoming when GI and hopefully Phillips makes a statment. Plenty of GI, Dave Phillips and board bashing going on at the moment based on assumptions. Ubderstasndibly so after all of the denial at the fans forum though I dont believe they would have openly lied to us that night In November. The easiest thing to have done would haave been to unload all of their responsibilities to the TUST and let the fans run it but for whatever reasons they have chosen to go with the people they discribed as " not ideal bedfellows ". There's more to it, in my opinion than just wanting to recoup their original investement. So what, in the last six weeks hass changed? Whatever, Its imperative that we as supporters scrutinise intensly what is said when they do make a statment though these are clever experienced businessmen who know how to manouver and avoid answering truthfully and honestly. Personally I think now is the time for the likes of Jon etc to draw up a list of probing questions so we know right from the off exactly where we as supporters and the football club stand in their future plans.
|
|
Rob
TFF member
Posts: 3,607
Favourite Player: Asa Hall
|
Post by Rob on Dec 17, 2016 18:26:49 GMT
My GI 'bashing' is not based on assumption, Pete. I hope I have made that clear by my own personal experience as a fan of another sport club that no longer exists. You don't get over that.
I was aping his comments to rjd, Pete. I'll take your post on board, Pete. No problem. Emotions are running high right now. Mine included.
I agree with what you propose and with what you say regarding how clever these people are in terms of getting what they want. I decided to look back at the fans forum video and Jon's questions were very pertinent indeed.
|
|
petef
Match Room Manager
Posts: 4,626
|
Post by petef on Dec 17, 2016 18:48:04 GMT
Re the video Rob I must admit I skipped through it the first time as it was very long and un-edited and I was in a bad place regarding the club after just witnessing such an apaLling display against Southport. I honestly had no idea you had personal experince of this organisation.
Well we have a short period of time to get some even more pertinent and probing questions together and absolutly demand honest answers or walk out. If they are not answered we will know they are concealing the truth.
|
|
Rob
TFF member
Posts: 3,607
Favourite Player: Asa Hall
|
Post by Rob on Dec 17, 2016 18:49:16 GMT
Hey Flo. Continuous bashing of a supporters group. 'Let it go' love. Not really, Rob. Those are the words of one man. He may lead TUST but I doubt he went for their consensus before unleashing his diatribe. Just reading around it's perhaps fair to say it captured the mood, no? I'm one of those like alpine who reads all three forums, mind.
|
|